Money and business in the Middle East.

AI

Anthropic says Claude agents solved two open black hole problems

Anthropic reported Claude Fable 5.2 closed two unsolved theoretical physics problems on black holes.

· Last verified: 19 Nov 2026 (Anthropic)

Summary

  • Anthropic reported Claude Fable 5.2 closed two unsolved theoretical physics problems on black holes.
  • One finished a 2003 calculation left incomplete; the other tightened a 2011-era mathematical bound.
  • A physicist reviewed every main result and Lean verified the bootstrap proof.

The latest

Two open problems in black hole theory were solved by Claude agents, Anthropic's science team said in a November 17, 2026 post, with results checked by a proof assistant and reviewed by a physicist. One agent completed a quantum gravity calculation abandoned since 2003; another derived a sharper limit on the lightest possible black hole mass in three-dimensional gravity.

Details

  • The first problem: Anthropic said Claude settled whether the Hawking-Page transition in N=4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory is abrupt or smooth at weak coupling. The calculation required a three-loop coefficient and thousands of diagrams. Claude found the transition is abrupt, matching Hawking and Page's 1983 result.
  • The method: A small set of Claude instances ran the Hawking-Page work, with nearly every step computed twice independently, according to Anthropic. A physicist running Claude separately on the same problem reached a matching result; a colleague noted the Anthropic agent got there first.
  • The second problem: On the modular bootstrap for three-dimensional gravity, Anthropic said Claude derived an exact ceiling on the lightest black hole mass, M₁ ≤ c/Λ with Λ approximately 9.1266, and showed the bound is optimal for that form of the method.
  • The comparison: Earlier numerical work pointed to roughly c/9.1, while the best previously proven bound was c/8.5, credited to Hartman, Mathys and Rastelli. The new ceiling still falls short of c/12, the threshold where black holes begin to appear, Anthropic said.
  • The failures: Anthropic disclosed that 61 parallel Claude attempts failed on the bootstrap problem before a separate agent connected the method to a sphere-packing result recently proven by an OpenAI model. Two further agents independently arrived at the same answer.
  • The origin: Anthropic researcher Hongbin Chen tested Claude on the work as a side project in August, the company said. Claude proposed 22 candidate problems, and separate agents worked on them for about six weeks.
  • The verification: Lean, a computer proof checker, verified the modular bootstrap results in September, according to Anthropic. Claude wrote the paper with limited human direction, and a physicist reviewed every major result before publication.
  • The limits: Anthropic stated plainly that neither result describes our universe directly and that neither has practical applications. The two papers were posted as preprints, numbered 2611.00175v1 for Hawking-Page and 2611.00174v1 for the modular bootstrap.
  • Also: Neither result describes our universe or carries practical applications, Anthropic said.

Background

The Hawking-Page transition, identified in 1983, describes the point at which a gas of particles collapses into a black hole. The 2003 weak-coupling calculation that would test it at that regime was never completed until now, according to Anthropic.

Between the lines

The disclosed failure count is the most revealing number here: 61 parallel attempts collapsed before a different agent found the sphere-packing link. That suggests the breakthrough came from routing between methods rather than raw computation. Anthropic's own framing — no practical applications, no description of our universe — positions the claim as a capability demonstration, not a physics event.

What's next

Independent physicists have not yet publicly assessed the two preprints. Watch for peer response to the Λ ≈ 9.1266 bound, and whether other labs replicate the agent-driven workflow on comparable open problems.

Source: Anthropic

Anthropic says Claude agents solved two open black hole problems · INXEN